Re: Brahms NIM Paper for Collaboration Wide Review

From: Peter H. L. Christiansen (pchristi@nbi.dk)
Date: Fri Sep 28 2001 - 11:35:24 EDT

  • Next message: Apache: "Shift report 20010929 16:00-24:00"

    Hi
    
    I have some comments after reading the first half of the paper. The first
    3 marked *** needs some inoput from other people, the rest are just
    misspellings :
    
    ***) The first figure, Y-Pt coverage, looks wrong to me for region III. It
    seems that it goes from 85 degrees instead of 95 degrees since y = 0 is
    not covered. Could the very nice person who made the macro change this.
    
    ***) Is the calculated drift velocity really 1.45 micro m/m s, I always
    heard 1.6
    
    ***) Isn't the size of the PMT's in C1, 2.5", that is at least what is in
    the detectorparameters.
    
    *)Figure 2 : ZDC IS now included
    
    *) Page 5, the first paragraph in Mid-Rapidity Spectrometer : MSR -> MRS
    
    *) Page 8, the first paragraph in Time Projection Chambers :
    Particle multiplicities in the each TPC -> remove the
    
    *) Page 14, second paragraph Cherekov Detectors : has a radius -> has a
    maximum radius
    
    Cheers
       Peter
    



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Fri Sep 28 2001 - 11:36:08 EDT