Re: [Brahms-l] A request from a PHENIX member (pp and AuAu spectracomparison)

Hi Flemming,

   thanks for your reply. I was worried about the data policy, that's 
why I did not give him the numbers, but the figure only.

Best regards,
  Hongyan

Flemming Videbaek wrote:

> Dear Hongyan,
>
> Our stated philosophy is that actual numbers of PRELIMINARY  data are 
> not given to anyone outside the collaboration; only after the papers 
> that contains the data are published in a refereed journal will we
> post the numbers, and make tables available.
>
> People from PHENIX should know better than asking; All the RHIC 
> experiments have the same data policy.
> Actually the PHENIX one is more stringent, in so far it only allow to 
> show preliminary data once i.e. after a particular spectrum has been 
> shown at a meeting, only that version of the spectrum can be shown 
> until the
> final data submission.
>
> So the short, but firm answer is NO; They can read the numbers of the 
> graphs if they want; we cannot prevent that but it is on their one peril.
>
>
> best regards
>    Flemming   
>
> --------------------------------------------
> Flemming Videbaek
> Physics Department Bldg 510-D
> Brookhaven National Laboratory
> Upton, NY11973
>
> phone: 631-344-4106
> cell:       631-681-1596
> fax:        631-344-1334
> e-mail: videbaek @ bnl gov
> ----- Original Message ----- From: "Hongyan Yang" <hongyan_at_ift.uib.no>
> To: <brahms-l_at_lists.bnl.gov>
> Sent: Friday, February 09, 2007 4:12 AM
> Subject: [Brahms-l] A request from a PHENIX member (pp and AuAu 
> spectracomparison)
>
>
>> Hi,
>>    I got a mail from a member from PHENIX after he read my 
>> contribution to QM06, asking for data points of our identified 
>> particles spectra in pp (200GeV) and AuAu (200GeV) at mid-rapidity 
>> for comparison. I have sent my comparison (figure) with 
>> PHENIX(published) and STAR (published) at y=0 to him, but not the 
>> numbers yet.
>>
>>   As to spectra of identified particles spectra in AuAu at 
>> mid-rapidity with different centrality, I do not have. So if any of 
>> you has been doing analysis on this, and have it in handy (or have 
>> done the comparison with them already), maybe it is good to have some 
>> communication with them.
>>
>> Best regards,
>>  Hongyan
>>
_______________________________________________
Brahms-l mailing list
Brahms-l_at_lists.bnl.gov
http://lists.bnl.gov/mailman/listinfo/brahms-l