Hi Kris (and all the rest of you) Thanks for the comments, > Michael tells me that the dotted line in figure 3 should > k-/k+ = (pbar/p)**1/3 (not 1/4) Which is correct? That shows up in > the fig4 caption and in text discussing it. Should there also be a > reference? I fitted the data points and got something very close to 1/4. I don't think 1/4 is more correct than 1/3, but it fits the data on the plot better (if there's any argument for 1/3 I'll be happy to change it). The idea to fit the data with this function is not inspiret by any paper (as far as I know). > For your comment regarding Becattini, I agree that it is too easy to > pull two points off a curve and plot a straight line. If it is coming > off a curve, one should make it a curve and not a straight line. And it > is a slight curve. Trine just send me curves (still read of the plot) for the Becattini predictions with T=160 and T=170. They still only go down to p/pbar=0.4, which is what is shown in the paper. I would like to get the dependence over the whole range (0-1), but I haven't heard from Becattini yet. > For your AMPT comment, I would support keeping it in, but at least put > the results on the figures and discuss that. Do we have the space for that? The Letter is now a bit more than 4 pages. I think I will take it out and then we can discuss if we want to put it back in - if somebody writes a good story about it, that is. I've got a load of small changes from JJ, Ole and Ian. I'll try to put draft 2.06 together on sunday (more comments are of course welcome in the mean time...). Cheers, Claus +-------------------------------------------------------------+ | Claus Jørgensen | | Cand. Scient. Phone : (+45) 33 32 49 49 | | Cell : (+45) 27 28 49 49 | | Niels Bohr Institute, Ta-2, Office : (+45) 35 32 53 07 | | Blegdamsvej 17, DK-2100, E-mail : ekman@nbi.dk | | University of Copenhagen Home : www.nbi.dk/~ekman/ | +-------------------------------------------------------------+
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Fri Jun 28 2002 - 20:14:34 EDT